Small battles with consequential choices
Steve Jackson’s Melee, published by Metagaming in 1977, presents individual combat on a hex map. Characters divide starting points between Strength and Dexterity, creating a direct tradeoff between physical power and effectiveness in combat. Wizard followed in 1978, adding Intelligence and magical combat. Together, the games formed the foundation of The Fantasy Trip.
A character is a set of decisions
Weapons, armor, positioning, and character construction give these little games their substance. A heavily protected fighter gains security at a cost; a powerful wizard must manage the resources spent on spells. Building a capable character does not remove the need to use that character well.
The games deserve a paired review because each illuminates the other. Melee establishes the physical contest, while Wizard adds a different range of possibilities. The later role-playing framework should be distinguished from these original standalone combat games.
Battleward verdict
Melee and Wizard are especially interesting from a rules designer’s perspective. A few understandable attributes produce decisions that matter during play. The useful lesson is how clearly a game can express a tradeoff without needing a separate procedure for every circumstance.
Sources and review basis
A research-based retrospective of the early game, drawing on the sources listed below. Battleward has not conducted a personal playtest. Assessments of strengths, limitations, and suitability are editorial judgments. Later editions are distinguished where relevant.
Conversation
Reader comments
Discuss the article and keep the conversation civil.
Tell us what worked, what fell short, or what this made you want to try.
Add your thoughts ↗Browse the forum ↗Loading comments…