Artillery Usage

Throughout history there have been many untold events that have become of immense importance or have faded into obscurity. whichever way, if you have a tidbit to share or a story to tell, please share with us.
Post Reply
Gene
Posts: 176
Joined: Tue Dec 26, 2023 12:16 am
United States of America

Artillery Usage

Post by Gene »

In designing a more common method of representing artillery within a game's framework, I decided to delve into the historical research involving artillery, its history, its innovations, its battlefield usage, and its overall doctrine. I also looked at each major nation's own defining characteristics of artillery. It was an eye-opening experience, but it is one I won't ever repeat. It took me over two years of reading and notetaking and for that I'm grateful, as normally I'm not so thorough as to include extensive notetaking.

Using a variety of sources- from published material to online sources to contacting the national archives of those nations involved in the Napoleonic Wars, I had to correlate the various records, and also the postwar artillery tests done by the English and Russians of their former enemies' equipment. It was not an easy task. I'm glad I did it, however.

The data on the different national records as well as some of the varied sources didn't always match up, when that happened, I had to extrapolate what I could, bringing the numbers to a more equitable balance. It really depends on who is noting the historical facts and how they perceive them. Unfortunately, it would seem even post 1815 there was an overabundance of bias and some of that entered the historical records.

To move on, here is my humble offering of what I perceive to be the more important aspects of each nation's artillery.

The strategies for employing artillery evolved throughout the wars, reflecting different military doctrines, technological capabilities, and tactical innovations by forward thinking leaders.

Here's a summation of how different nations typically used their artillery:

French Artillery
  • Innovative Use of Artillery: Napoleon Bonaparte is particularly noted for his innovative use of artillery. He often massed artillery into "grand batteries" which were used decisively to break enemy lines or weaken key positions before an infantry assault.
  • Support Role: French artillery was not only used in grand batteries but was also closely coordinated with infantry and cavalry, providing direct support during their engagements. This integrated approach was crucial in many of Napoleon's victories.

British Artillery
  • More Conservative Use: The British often used their artillery in a more traditional role, supporting infantry from set positions. British artillery was noted for its accuracy and effective long-range fire, partly due to the influence of naval gunnery techniques.
  • Counter-Battery Fire: British artillery was often used effectively to counter enemy artillery, focusing on disabling or destroying enemy guns before they could impact the battlefield significantly.

Prussian Artillery
  • Integration with Movements: Prussian military doctrine increasingly integrated artillery with infantry maneuvers, especially after reforms following earlier defeats by Napoleon. By the Wars of Liberation, Prussian artillery was more mobile and used in a combined arms context to support fast-moving infantry and cavalry attacks.
  • Defensive Roles: Initially, Prussian artillery also played significant roles in defensive situations, creating strong positions that could resist French attacks.

Russian Artillery
  • Defensive Emphasis: Russian artillery was often used defensively, taking advantage of Russia’s vast spaces and the need to defend against Napoleon’s advances. Russian artillery could decimate advancing troops trying to navigate the wide-open terrains.
  • Large Calibers: Russian artillery pieces were often larger and had a reputation for being robust, which made them less mobile but very powerful in defensive setups.

Austrian Artillery
  • Diverse Tactics: Austrian artillery tactics were somewhat varied; they used artillery to support infantry but also employed batteries to defend against enemy forces. The Austrians had a diverse array of artillery pieces, which they used depending on the tactical needs of the battle.
  • Slower to Modernize: Austrian artillery was sometimes less effectively used than the French due to slower modernization and organization issues.

General Use Across Nations
  • Defensive vs. Offensive: While some nations preferred to use artillery in a more static, defensive role, others, like the French, revolutionized the use of artillery as a mobile force capable of delivering devastating blows in an offensive capacity.
  • Separate Batteries vs. Integrated Support: Artillery was also used in separate batteries that could deliver fire over long distances without direct contact with the enemy, as well as in closer support roles where it was coordinated directly with the movements of infantry and cavalry.

The effectiveness of artillery during the Napoleonic Wars was thus not only a matter of firepower but also how well it was integrated into the overall military strategy and how it was adapted to the specific tactical situations of a battle.
Gene
Posts: 176
Joined: Tue Dec 26, 2023 12:16 am
United States of America

Re: Artillery Usage

Post by Gene »

I failed to add that I'll be using the aforementioned data in my app to differentiate between each nation's artillery (it'll be a bit more precise and detailed). Although in some instances this may prove to be problematic, if not extremely difficult. It is my fondest wish to create a baseline for other historical games that offer realism without the cost of over-the-top complexity, however. I truly believe this is one feasible method of achieving that goal. Although I began with Napoleonic artillery, other aspects of battle can be simulated realistically without the need for complex chart systems.

For example, muskets and rifles, their chance to hit equals range to target, plus training/experience minus fatigue equals damage inflicted. A statistical analysis of the data obtained in this manner can be made to create more realistic hit/damage tables without the need for additional and unwieldy charts.

Although my previous attempt at designing an app for artillery hit/damage was somewhat off the mark, it generated a lot of data that I'm sure is more realistic than simply "fudging" the table results.

I'm not sure I like the grouping of artillery and howitzers into a single item, as each operate differently, and their results can vary widely. Some games, like Bataille Empire, group them together so as to simplify play, however, howitzers tend to be used for different purposes than artillery. So maybe a "home rule" could be that a player designates whether howitzers are being used or artillery is firing. I think it would convey more realism than the current method used by Bataille Empire which simply includes howitzers as an afterthought.

Anyway, those are my thoughts and intents.
Gene
Posts: 176
Joined: Tue Dec 26, 2023 12:16 am
United States of America

Re: Artillery Usage

Post by Gene »

Further reading of my notes indicates that the French, as well as other nation's military forces, grouped their cannon with howitzers. And often, they fired together at the same targets. I simply forgot that small factoid. So, I beg you to forget what I mentioned previously about artillery groupings. Thank you.
Post Reply